Can a bread machine really make a good gluten-free, dairy-free loaf with freshly milled flour? I put it to the test—twice.

The Oven’s Out, the Experiment’s On

When my oven went out of commission, I had to get creative fast. I’m used to baking my own homemade bread from freshly milled flour, so not having fresh loaves on the counter wasn’t an option I wanted to accept. My daughter reminded me of our Cuisinart bread maker. I used to use it frequently in my pre-fresh-milled, gluten-free flour days. It’s a convenient way to keep baking while I wait for the repairs to be made.

The idea started simple: test a basic bread machine recipe for gluten-free bread, using my own flour freshly ground in the NutriMill Classic grain mill. But what began as a quick experiment turned into a full-blown two-loaf test, complete with a few surprises along the way.

Since this was my first time baking gluten-free bread in a bread machine, I wasn’t sure what to expect. Would the texture hold up without dairy or gluten? Could fresh milled flour, which is different from store-bought white flours, work in a machine designed primarily for traditional bread?

It turns out the short answer is yes, but it took a couple of tries (and a forgotten paddle) to get there.

Why Bread Machines and Fresh-Milled Gluten-Free Flour Don’t Always Mix

If you’ve baked much gf bread, you already know it’s a different world from regular bread. There’s no gluten structure to help it rise and hold shape, so the balance of wet ingredients to dry ingredients has to be just right. Add fresh milled flour to the mix, made from whole grains with natural oils and fiber, and you’ve got another layer of complexity.

Every grain mill produces flour with its own unique texture and moisture content, which affects how the dough behaves. That’s why a flour mix from the store often behaves differently from freshly milled flour from your kitchen. My loaves usually bake in the oven, typically in my chosen vessels, which are stoneware or cast iron. But with the oven out, I wanted to see how my Cuisinart handled it on the gluten-free setting.

I have to say, the ease of use surprised me (at least on the second round). The machine handled mixing, kneading, and rise cycles without issue, and the whole process felt like a convenient way to test whether homemade gluten-free bread could still be great without an oven.

Round One – The Gluten-Free Sandwich Bread Flop

For the first test, I decided to start simple and follow the Cuisinart sandwich bread recipe straight from the manual. It’s a 1½-lb loaf, explicitly designed for the gluten-free setting, and it seemed like the best place to start. I milled and measured out my flour blend, added the wet ingredients in order into the bread machine: warm water, dairy-free butter, and large eggs—and then the dry ingredients: cups of flour, salt, psyllium husk powder, and active dry yeast (you could also use bread machine yeast or instant yeast for similar results).

Since this was my first time baking gluten-free bread in a machine, I followed the instructions closely. I poured the wet ingredients into the bread pan first, then layered the dry ingredients on top, just as the manual suggested. The kneading paddle went to work, mixing everything into a soft, sticky dough that looked promising during the dough cycle and the first rise.

Everything seemed fine until I remembered too late that I hadn’t removed the kneading paddle before baking. The loaf finished with a domed crust on top, but a deep tunnel running right through the center. When I turned it out to cool, it looked more like a cave than a loaf of homemade bread.

Despite the appearance, the final product surprised me. It was a little heavy, but the texture was soft, and it tasted a lot like regular bread, especially fresh from the machine. It wasn’t the prettiest loaf, but it was encouraging. Aside from that hollow middle, it had good flavor, a balanced crumb, albeit a little dense, and a mild finish.

For a first try, I called it a partial win. The bread had the right aroma, sliced nicely once cooled, and made excellent toast the next day. Still, I knew I could do better. The paddle mistake aside, I wanted to see if I could improve the shape, color, and structure by testing a different flour blend from the manual’s multigrain recipe next time. This time, I’d ensure I remembered to remove the paddle and shape the dough before the bake cycle.

Round Two – The Gluten-Free Multigrain Bread Success

After the sandwich loaf’s “Swiss cheese” moment, I was determined to try again, this time with the gluten-free multigrain recipe from the Cuisinart manual. It used a slightly different flour mix that included whole-grain ingredients and starches for better texture. I milled a blend of whole grain brown rice and white rice in the grain mill, then combined them with milled oats, flaxseed meal, arrowroot, and a bit of psyllium husk to help the dough hold together. The flour mix smelled nutty and fresh, a good sign right from the start.

I measured everything carefully, using warm water, dairy-free butter, and large eggs again as the base wet ingredients. The dry ingredients included a freshly ground flour blend, 1 tsp of salt, and a small amount of instant yeast. Gluten-free doughs often need enough time in the dough cycle to hydrate fully before the final rise, which the Cuisinart bread machine allowed for.

This time, when the machine beeped signaling the cycle completion, I paused before the bake cycle, removed the kneading paddle, and gently reshaped the dough in the bread pan for a smoother top. That one small change made all the difference. The loaf baked evenly, rose beautifully, and developed a soft, dark crust.

When I finally lifted the final product out to cool, it looked (and smelled) amazing. The texture was tender but sturdy, and slicing was easy. The crumb was uniform and springy, and the flavor was rich and balanced, with a slightly nutty undertone and a hint of sweetness from the whole grains. This was truly delicious gluten-free bread, the kind you’d never guess came from a machine. It didn’t have the dense feel some gf bread recipes can have, and it held together beautifully even the next day.

For me, that was the proof. The whole process had gone smoothly from start to finish, and I’d gotten the best results yet from a bread machine recipe using fresh milled flour. It was every bit as satisfying as traditional bread, especially when I didn’t have an oven to rely on!

The experiment left me with a new appreciation for the ease of use of modern bread machines. With the right ingredients and a little patience, even small compact bread machines can handle different types of bread surprisingly well. And while this loaf may not have earned a formal star rating, in my kitchen, it got a solid five out of five for flavor, texture, and reliability. I’ll definitely make this one again!

What I Learned (and What You Should Know)

Testing both recipes side by side taught me something new about fresh-milled gluten-free bread, especially when using a bread machine instead of an oven. If you’re planning to try your own recipes, here are a few lessons (and minor adjustments) that made all the difference.

1. Temperature and hydration matter.

Use warm water (not hot) when adding your wet ingredients. Gluten-free doughs need proper hydration to rise, especially with fresh flour that hasn’t been sitting on a shelf. Whole-grain flour absorbs more moisture than store-bought all-purpose flour, so you may need to add a tablespoon or two of extra water as needed. You want a thick, sticky batter that is soft enough for the paddles to move, but not so loose that it sloshes.

2. Let the dough cycle do its thing.

Even though you’re not kneading gluten strands, the dough setting helps fully hydrate the grains and psyllium husks. I also found that pausing after the mix cycle to scrape the sides or remove air pockets gives a better structure. A short rest before baking helps prevent uneven rise or tunneling.

3. Remove the paddle before baking.

This one simple step gives you a cleaner loaf bottom and a more even bake. After shaping the dough gently in the bread pan, I let it continue into the final rise and bake cycle. You’ll be rewarded with a more uniform loaf that looks as good as it tastes.

4. Cool it completely before slicing.

It’s tempting to cut into warm bread, but resist the urge. I thought I had allowed it to cool long enough both times, but I didn’t! Allowing the bread to cool on a rack prevents it from becoming gummy and helps set its texture. Fresh-milled loaves often have a bit more internal moisture, and cooling allows that steam to redistribute evenly.

5. Plan for a shorter shelf life, or slice and freeze.

Because fresh flour lacks preservatives, homemade gluten-free loaves won’t last long at room temperature. Mine stayed soft for two days before starting to dry out. To extend freshness, store in the refrigerator, or try slicing the loaf after cooling and freezing it in small portions. It toasts beautifully straight from the freezer.

6. Think beyond sandwich loaves.

Once you understand your bread machine’s settings, it’s easy to branch out and experiment with different options. The best results come from paying attention to texture and timing. So, if your bread maker is gathering dust or you’ve been hesitant to try fresh flour in it, consider this your nudge to plug it in and start testing. You might discover your new favorite loaf, straight from your kitchen counter.

Fresh-Milled Breadmaker Success

Can you make a decent loaf of gluten-free, dairy-free bread in a bread machine?

Short answer: yes, absolutely! It took a couple of tries, a few adjustments, and one paddle mishap, but the second loaf proved it’s possible to bake delicious gluten-free bread using fresh-milled flour, even without an oven!

Once you understand how your breadmaker handles gluten-free dough, you can adjust factors such as hydration, resting time, or crust color to suit your own preferences.

Until my oven is fixed, I’ll be baking homemade bread this way, and honestly, I’m not mad about it. The final product is soft, flavorful, and full of the wholesome goodness that only whole grains and freshly milled flour can bring.

If you’ve got a grain mill, a breadmaker, and a bit of curiosity, give this method a try. It’s a convenient way to enjoy real, fresh bread at home without settling for store-bought or sacrificing nutrition.

Save $20 on a Nutrimill Grain Mill with code VINTAGEVIRTUES at https://nutrimill.com/VINTAGEVIRTUES

And for those who want to test it themselves, I’ll share the winning recipe (from the Cuisinart manual) that worked beautifully with fresh-milled flour and simple ingredients. It’s proof that with the right bread machine recipe, you can create a loaf that rivals traditional bread, minus the gluten or dairy.

The Recipe That Finally Worked

The second loaf, Cuisinart’s Gluten-Free Multigrain Bread, was the clear winner. I used fresh-milled flour in place of the standard gluten-free flour mix, added dairy-free butter, warm water, large eggs, and yeast, and ran it on the gluten-free setting.

After the dough cycle, I removed the kneading paddle, shaped the dough, and let it complete its final rise before baking. The result? A soft, sliceable loaf that looked like regular bread but tasted even better. It’s fresh, hearty, and perfect for sandwiches or toast.

Recipe adapted from the Cuisinart Bread Maker Manual.

Affiliate Disclosure

This blog post contains affiliate links, including Amazon Associate links. Purchases made through these links help support Gluten-Free Heritage at no additional cost to you. Thank you for supporting this work!